Obama a Follower, Not a Leader
WASHINGTON & SANTA
FE, NM (By Dana
Milbank, WP)
September 1, 2011―
Labor boss Richard
Trumka is not one to
nibble around the
edges.
He declined a plate
of bacon and eggs
when sitting down to
breakfast with a
group of reporters
this week because,
the AFL-CIO
president explained,
he was concerned he
might spit out a
mouthful if he
didn’t like a
question.
The stains on his
Brooks Brothers
necktie suggested
this was more than a
theoretical
possibility.
So perhaps it should
not be a surprise
Trumka has lost
patience with the
Great Nibbler in our
civic life,
President Obama.
The president, he complained, has been doing “little nibbly things around the edge that aren’t going to make a difference and aren’t going to solve the problem” with the economy.
Obama, he protested, decided to “work with the Tea Party to offer cuts to middle-class programs like Social Security.”
And, Trumka accused,
Obama has limited
his proposals to
“those little things
that he thinks
others will
immediately accept.”
Without bolder
action on the
economy, Trumka told
the gathering,
organized by the
Christian Science
Monitor, “I think he
doesn’t become a
leader anymore, and
he’s being a
follower.”
This is harsh
criticism of a
Democratic president
from a natural ally
— and it’s backed up
by labor’s plans to
create its own
“super PAC” rather
than give money to
the Democrats.
The criticism is
justified, as the
former miner
outlined it, because
Obama is on his way
to a failed
presidency if he
doesn’t change
course with the
rollout of his new
jobs program next
month.
“I said to him, ‘Do
not look at what is
possible — look at
what is necessary,”
Trumka said,
recounting a recent
White House meeting
when he urged the
president to offer
more than modest
programs Republicans
support. “If you
only propose what
you think they’ll
accept, they control
the agenda,” Trumka
said. “I urged him
to propose what was
necessary to solve
the problem . . .
and if he doesn’t
and he falls into
the nibbling around
the edge, I think
history will judge
him and I think
working people will
judge him.”
As a practical
matter, the sort of
actions labor favors
— $4 trillion in
infrastructure
spending, a WPA-type
jobs program and the
like — aren’t going
to happen.
As a matter of
economics, they may
not be efficient or
desirable ways to
fix the economy.
But Trumka still
makes a good point,
for reasons beyond
economics or
practicality —
because this isn’t
primarily about
enacting new policy.
It’s about building
confidence in
Obama’s leadership
as the economy
flails.
If Obama is to
dispel the growing —
and debilitating —
impression he is a
weak leader, he
needs to show people
he’s willing to
fight for something
other than his tee
time. “We’re going
in the wrong
direction,” Trumka
said. “There has to
be some hope that
we’re going to turn
it around. That
means there have to
be some bold
solutions and some
risk taking.”
According to a poll
released Thursday by
the nonpartisan Pew
Research Center, the
proportion of
Americans who regard
Obama as a strong
leader has dropped
to 49 percent from
58 percent three
months ago, and the
percentage who
believe Obama can
get things done has
dropped to 44 from
55.
A majority of
independents now
regard Obama as
unable to get things
done, and a majority
of Democrats think
he should be tougher
against the
Republicans.
The president,
however, remains
unconcerned.
Would he call Congress back from recess to address the jobs crisis? He would not.
Neither would he cancel his vacation on a $50,000-per-week Martha’s Vineyard compound.
When the earthquake struck the East Coast, he was on the golf course.
On the day Trumka
complained about the
need for action,
Obama spent nearly
five hours on the
beach with his
family, then went to
dinner with friends.
Now Obama is
promising a new jobs
plan — after he
returns from the
beach.
The AFL-CIO chief,
for one, is worried
it will be the same
old mix of tax
breaks,
infrastructure banks
and patent reforms.
“That’s not going to
get the job done,”
he said.
This is why the
labor boss has, in
his private sessions
with Obama and in
his meeting with
reporters, urged
Obama to demand more
than he expects.
“You need leadership
with a sharp cutting
edge to say, ‘This
is what I stand for,
this is what they
stand for,’” Trumka
said. “Give them the
narrative about why
it will work,”
rather than “more of
the same of, ‘we’re
muddling along."










